Why did the U.N. support Israel?

Why does America support Israel so much?

  • First let me say that I think its pretty crappy that the Arabs, who had been the largest ethnic group in the region for 1200 years, had their land taken from them by the UN to make a Jewish state. And because of something they had nothing to do with! Now, why does the United States give Israel so much support? We give them over 3 billion dollars in aid a year! But why? Some people like to say its because they are our only military ally in the area. But they have not sent a single solider to Iraq or Afghanistan, or any other country that we are currently fighting terrorism in. And yes, it would seem that America would be willing to attack a common enemy in Iran, but I can't help but wonder if America would have a dog in the fight at all if it never supported Israel. And I know that the Palestinians shoot rockets into Israeli held territory. Not saying that or any other attacks by Hamas are okay. But Israel has had some pretty bad human rights issues themselves. They go into places and demolish thousands of homes, displacing countless Palestinian families. And there have been signifigantly more Palestinian civilians killed than Israeli civialians. Heck, just read up on the conditions of Gaza due to the Israeli blockade, or this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Fact_Finding_Mission_on_the_Gaza_Conflict#Accusations_against_Israel But why does the United States fund all of this? What exactly does America have to gain? What self interest does it serve? And is it all part of a giant self fullfilling prophecy of "they hate us because we give money to Israel, and we give money to Israel because they hate us"? Is the US govenrment just THAT in favor of democracy? Or do Americans hate just really, reallly dislike the idea of Islam controlling the Holy Land? Or is there just something I'm missing?

  • Answer:

    Because the Israel lobby - which is in fact largely constituted of evangelical Christians - is extremely wealthy and extremely influential in American politics and in shaping American public opinion. No US congressman is going to stand up and tell the truth about America's relationship with Israel if they know they're going to have AIPAC throwing all their weight and funding behind their opponent when the elections roll round. No public figure or academic is going to try to talk sense about Israel if they're going to be drowned out with accusations of anti-semitism, and potentially risk losing their job. The intimidation and the bullying is nothing short of censorship. If you have time, read this article by Walt and Mearsheimer from the LRB. It's very long - and it's a few years old - but it sets out the case against the Israel lobby very clearly and with devastating effect: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v28/n06/john-mearsheimer/the-israel-lobby

Poppycoc... at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

because if you don't they will destroy you. they have a lot of power. ask any politician.

jazz41

Because the American leaders have sold out Americas interest for the zionist interest. The U.S. government is infact controlled by the zionist, there are many zionist in congress and they control most of the mass media. They have their interest and the politicians have theirs and the American peoples interest comes after theirs.

onio

What's interesting is that Muslims are extremely anti-gay, but liberals think they just need to be understood. They sympathize with them, but not Christians, who they decry. Dan Savage would never sabotage Achmadinejad's presence on Google and he brutally EXECUTES gay people, but he did do it to Santorum. Go figure. The Palestinians also have a record of actual hostility to gays, but liberals won't say a word. In the name of diversity, of course.

The Tea Party=America's only hope

Why are some people so firmly conitted to ignoring history and at the same time, focusing their intense hatred in the Jews.

Seiko .

Everything america does is in her own self interest or to promote her self image. Money and politics that is what everything boils down to.

M aiq the liar

America is in the evil grip of zionists.Muslims can understand your pathetic position.

Muslim SunniSalafi Ahlehadith

I know that I probably won't get best answer but this is just ridiculous! guess what? I'M A PALESTINIAN. I am christian though and My mom is american so I live in america but I was raised in my family's refugee camp and now i go there every summer so I am very close to them. I just commented to clear up some of the misconceptions... First, to answer your question... it's basically because Israel is an ally and because they are extremely wealthy and influential. now, I'm going to clear up the misconceptions about palestinians... 1. about homosexuals... my male best friend is gay and two of my female friends are lesbians, and I love them with my life. And i was raised with those "palestinians that execute gay people" You do understand that there are gay people in the refugee camps and they are still alive right? yes, there are muslims who despise homosexual as there are also christians, jews, atheists, etc. Why say just palestinian muslims? Most of the people in the camp are fine with them. 2. palestinians did send rockets, but guess what? If you went through all of that crap, with Israel killing palestinians and palestinian children and you had a chance to throw rockets at the army that may have killed your friends or your family, you would do it. doesn't mean it's right but those are just human reactions to your feelings of rage and sadness. AND THE PALESTINIANS ROCKETS ARE NOT OF THE SAME MAGNITUDE AS THE ISRAELI'S ROCKETS AND MISSLES FROM AMERICA! 3. and seriously, people being put inside of camps and being killed by the country/state they are in because of their race... doesn't that sound a little familiar about what israel had to go through? 4. Muslims are not savages. islam doesn't say to kill or anything. on the contrary they are supposed to pray five times a day and not curse and give 5 percent of their money to charity (no lie). you think that because of what you see on t.v. but I can recall christians killing brutally like the romans back in the day and america now has killed children too, not as much as other places but still... no matter what state or country you are in, there will almost always be a history of killings. I hate that fact, but it's the truth. 5. My family back at the camp are amazing people. If you visited them you would be treated like loyalty! If you said, oh, that table looks nice, they would try to give it to you! They know I am christian and they know that I love homosexuals and they know that I have Israeli friends. and they don't judge me. so please don't go assuming things about the palestinians. but one of the stereo types are true... they are hotheaded! lol. That's the only one I believe. do you even know how the camp is like? their food is low quality and they only have limited things there. there are bombed buildings and they are trying to rebuild and a lot of the camp is mostly made up of narrow alleys... it's sad but for america... they do have a habit of doing things in their benefit and nobody else. No, not america, just the government. @ls: There are many muslims as you say that kill because they say that the q'uran says to kill other religions and that islam is the only religion allowed to live and go to heaven and other proposterous things such as those. And there are palestinians like that as well, I'm just saying that a lot of people thinks that EVERY muslim is like that and on the contrary, islam is not like that. Such as a catholic saying that everybody who's not catholic will go to hell. it doesn't say that in the bible either. I know about the muslim religion because my dad had me read the q'ran. and i DID NOT say that they are their ally because they are wealthy and influential. I said that they are an ally AND it helps that they are wealthy and influential as well. 2: wheter they try hard to minimize civilian death, which is good... but the point is that palestinians still die. it's been one thousand and three hundred in counting. a person brought up to the israeli's about the palestinian's freedom and they closed it off and ignored the speaker. it was their home too. 3: They aren't trying to destroy israel. that is stupid. They're trying to be free again. do you even know what conditions they live under? would you like pictures? because i do have them. and by the way, My uncle is israeli so i'm not racist towards them and it doesn't match up to the holocaust by any means at all, but it could become like that if israeli gets tired of them. you said yourself that the israeli's could have destroyed them decades ago. 4: I do agree with you to a point though. The palestinians are stupid. I already told my family, you have to use your head and not your fist all the damn time! there will never be peace this way, I know. I just don't think it's right that the palestinians are one of the few, if not the only race that are not free.

Amanda Wehbe

"But they have not sent a single solider to Iraq or Afghanistan, or any other country that we are currently fighting terrorism in..." Because they are not ALLOWED to go to Afghanistan and Iraq. This is Middle Eastern Conflicts 101, so if you didn't catch this detail right off the bat then I have to assume that you know nothing the Middle East.. That, and because they do not have to send soldiers out to places where American soldiers are, just because they are allies. They are a separate country, with their own government, their own military, their own laws, their own policies. They don't have to join us at war. Israel was won in the same way that Louisiana was won from France.

Zestfully Clean

you think we're going to support the savage muslims?

John

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.