Find solution
What Is Computer Graphic In Hindi Language?

Why don't Indians realize Hindi is an artificial language & a deviant of Urdu (read details of the question)?

  • Indians confuse the histories of Hindi and Urdu. Let’s call the language that developed during Muslim rule over the Indian subcontinent “X”, not Hindi or Urdu. Look at it from the script. Urdu is defined by its Nastaliq script, Hindi is defined by its original Sanskritized Devanagari script. The Nastaliq script for “X” is older than the Sanskritized/Hindi Devanagari script for “X” (not talking about the Sanskrit language). The reason why the Hindi-Urdu controversy took place in 1867 was because literary work in Nastaliq was being converted into Sankskritized Devanagari. Even till 1947, Nastaliq was more popular than Devanagari. Also, “X” had more Persian-Arabic derived & few Sanskrit derived words in it than present day Shudh Hindi does, & it was pretty much like present day Urdu (read Ghalib's poetry for example, a Hindi speaker can't understand it). That means that Urdu is older than Hindi by default. While Sanskrit language written in the Sankrit Devanagari script for Holy Scriptures is older than both Urdu & Hindi, Urdu is older than Hindi. Hindi is an artificial language, an innovation. I’ve provided enough proof that Indians are wrong with their lies.

  • Answer:

    No language is "artificial", it just develops with time. Urdu did, and so did Hindi. and by the way, the presently spoken hindi(spoken by most of the North Indians) is not "Shudh Hindi", its "Hindustani", a mixture of so many ancient languages, like Persian, Arabic, Sanskrit, and even Roman. Hindustani also includes words and expressions from the regional dialects. Hindustani was easily accepted in India because most of the people could speak it, those who couldn't, could at least understand it. Now, it is highly derogatory to call a language "artificial". A language could be more recent as compared to the other, but not "artificial"! Maybe your facts are right, but you must realize this point that its the human being who develop a language with course of time, it doesn't just drop off from the heavens. Maybe, presently spoken Urdu is much different from the one which was spoken 200 years ago, even that was created by humans only, so did Hindi(or Hindustani is present date). Hindi might be newer, but not artificial!

watashik... at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Every country has a history. Since you are writing this, I assume that you know the Indian history. So you know how Muslims came to India and started ruling our land. Then there was a time when Hindus and Muslims started getting along well. They were best friends! It was the British which ruined the Hindu-Muslim relationship! They applied the divide-and-rule principle and that is the reason why India and Pakistan are different countries today! Now Hindi was a language that majority people could speak and that includes both Hindus and Muslims. That is why Hindi came into existence. It is not an artificial language. It is a language that is understood by majority people. A language serves its purpose when people understand it and Hindi serves its purpose! Even today we are slaves to the Britishers 'cause if we weren't, then India and Pakistan would have been friends and we would not be writing and reading English! So stop thinking like a child and note that its not Hindi's mistake it is young! In fact, it was Hindi that kept Hindus and Muslims united so that British would go away. This is just my view. No offense to the British. Hope I was helpful! :)

Advice?

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.